We went here for my birthday this year. I was really craving seafood especially Scallops and Shrimp. We lucked out because Concerts on the Square was postponed that night due to rain in the forecast. (it didn't rain of course). First, the place is styling - very nice design and very impressive. It is small - but not tiny and it is fancy - but we felt OK in dress casual. They serve these pea pods while you wait for your food and they were very interesting and quite fun to eat. We both tried the crabcakes and they were good. Not quite what I expected, but good. Our dinners were good too - just didn't blow our socks off. They did bring me an unbelievable dessert for my birthday. That was very impressive.
I was "in-between" three and four stars just because I hadn't decided yet on this place. It was good enough to try again - but not so outstanding that I want to go this week.