Coconut chocolate chunk is amazing. Peppermint chip also rocks. They aren't kidding with their use of chocolate pieces. The ice cream is high quality and they do have some interesting flavors. I'm a big fan of Ben and Jerry's, but if you are looking for something a little simpler, this is a good option. There are plenty of tables (and benches outside) to hang out here, or you can grab a pint to go. It does get very busy in the summer, but the line moves quickly. If it were a bit less expensive, I would give it 5 stars.
By the way, last time I checked you can find Mitchell's at the nearby Heinens as well.