Overall, our party had a great time here. We loved the atmosphere, our waitress was great, and the wine was quite good. The dish I ordered, however, had to be one of the saltiest concoctions I've ever eaten and was almost inedible. So don't try the Pasta Puttanesca - not that anyone would anyway.
The Eggplant Parmigiana was very good, and we ordered seconds on garlic bread due to excessive deliciousness.
As far as I can tell, just stay away from the dish I tried and Bellitalia will treat you well.