I love this place! The servers are all so friendly, and accommodating, the portions are large, and it always tastes fresh!
My boyfriend and I go in here on a semi regular basis. We recognize some of the servers, and they know who we are. We also come with his mother and little sister for family dinners and are never disappointed.
The ONLY poor experience we have had there was the last time we went in. We, just he and I, ordered the Big Beefsro Salad to share. In terms of size, we were not disappointed, the salad was HUGE. But we did not like the flavors at all. We each maybe had 4 or 5 bites, which barely touched the salad, and had to order something else. Our waitress asked if we liked it and we informed her we couldn't eat it. She commented on how little of it we ate, that it barely looked touched and took it away. We ordered our normal pizza, and ate that just fine. When we received the bill the salad was on it, so I asked our server if there was any way we could remove it, or at least discount it, since we didn't even eat it. She looked at us and walked away to the bar filled someone Else's drink and came back to check if we were ready to pay.
In the end we paid for it, and left, still tipped her well, even if she wasn't willing to help us.
Other than that one experience though, every time we go in we are treated very well. It's always busy at dinner time, so come early! I highly recommend the Boom Dip, Toasted Ravioli Espanol, Bistro Sweet Po's, Thin Crust Pizza with sausage and pepperoni, the Chicago Stuffed Pizza with pepperoni (order this one To-Go, at the beginning of your meal as it takes 40-45 minutes to make and enjoy pizza all week at home!), and of course the Original Pizza Cookie (my favorite is the Peanut Butter!)!