It took me a long time to "get" this place. Like 5 years.
I don't love spicy tomato sauce on a pizza (and this is spicy and oregano-y) and the crust is bright yellow!! But in time I found I loved this pizza. Quality ingredients, a fair deal, quick, fresh pies, BYOB, a friendly, low-key atmosphere.
Strange, and definitely Pittsburgh.
UPDATE: I can't believe I forgot to mention the amazing discovery I had right before I left Pittsburgh - the tiramisu at Mineo's is pretty good. Maybe a little too sweet, but it does not taste like the fridge. At this price, and in this town (sad but true), that's saying a lot. For example, at the famous Dish the desserts taste like the fridge.
Oh, and the ice cream is not exactly quality, but I liked it. If you are serious about mint, the peppermint patty is an experience.