The product at The Healthy Butcher is amazing. Great selection of a wide variety of meats and lots of prepared chilled stuff too. It's also really convenient to get to.
Two stars are lost for the price. I know organic meat is expensive - actually I expect it to be. But the pricing at The Healthy Butcher far surpassed what we anticipated. We bought two chicken breasts that cost us $32.00, while comparable organic grass fed chicken from the big-box grocery store we usually go to are $10-12.
Unfortunately I really don't ever see myself going back to The Healthy Butcher, unless I'm in a pinch for dinner and unable/unwilling/too-lazy-on-a-winter-day to go elsewhere.