Butler Plumbing has done 2 jobs for me in my 1923 house.
Both were completed on time and with no fuss - no muss. I love it when tradesmen/women come on time.
Job 1 - they replaced the 3 gallon pink toilet with a new 1.5 gallon white one.
one year later - Job 2 - they replaced the bathroom sink faucet - and told me why it probably broke.
They do seem pricey - but I did get bids for job 1 and they came in at the same price as others -
SO, I did not even get a bid for job 2 - I just hired Butler. I really feel they are an honest family-run firm. They came out at 8 am and were done at 9 am. and I had a shiny new faucet that did not leak all over the counter.
Now-- if only the water here was not so limey- it would stay clean. sigh.