DO NOT GET BREAKFAST AT THE CUP!
I can't speak to their coffee, gelato, or anything else, but my wife and I had breakfast there and it was way overpriced for what it was.
We ordered waffles with eggs and bacon, two bagels with cream cheese, and a peach smoothie - totaling around $22. The waffles were 100% frozen toaster waffles. And not even Eggo waffles - they tasted like generic frozen waffles. The scrambled eggs were okay I guess, and the bacon was halfway decent. The bagels tasted cheap and stale, and they didn't even put the cream cheese on the bagels. The peach smoothie was decent, although it didn't taste like it had actual peaches in it but rather it tasted like frozen concentrate.
We will never be going to The Cup again.