I love the the whole vibe of the Playhouse Square District. The theatres are beautiful, the entertainment top-notch, ample nearby parking (free if you are willing to walk a block or two).
So why only three stars? Simply put, the staff! My mother and I have been subscribers for years and each year the renewal process is worse than the one before. The sales staff are pushy and demanding and not willing to even discuss other seating options.
More than likely my last year with renewal, I would just as soon save the money and buy better tickets to the one or two shows that I really want to see.