Wow. After reading all of the glowing Yelp reviews I went to this place expecting some seriously next level pizza. Imagine my disappointment when what we got was more like very greasy, very thick cardboard with very little flavor.
We ordered two different kinds of pizza - the "red top" and the margarita. They tasted almost exactly the same. They were both covered in puddles of oil. The crust was thick and hard throughout, making eating more like work than a reward.
If you want to compete in the awesome pizza category at this price point in this neighborhood, you've simply got to do better. I can't see any reason I would ever return here with Piccolo right up the block.