So I went back and tried something different. I ordered both green tea and cookie crazy with blended m&m!!! And omg it's amazing! The small is $5.49 (I'm actually uncertain) and the large is $5.99. However because I added m&m, I believe it was an extra $0.50. I do believe the first time I went I wasn't impressed because the flavor I chose wasn't that amazing. First time I ordered rocky road. But now I found my two flavors that I love and crave! The pricing is fair since it's a special kind of ice cream and they make it in front of you rather than just scooping it up from a container.