The Fish Tacos are what brings me to Hickory Tavern for lunch. They are absolutely fantastic. However, the rest of the menu I haven't had much success. Nothing bad, just nothing that sticks out and says wow.
The desserts are MASSIVE, and I would recommend sharing if you get one. The oreo cheesecake and the tiramisu cheesecakes are especially good.
They do offer trivia on Wednesday nights where you can win gift certificates (and apply them to your bill that night).
Again, 3 stars for having some good food, but I don't yearn to go there every week.