Ate at Brothers last night without the benefit of reading any reviews beforehand. A friend suggested it, so off we went.
I read reviews this morning and noticed that my experience was entirely different than many of the posted reviews. Here are a few highlights:
1. The space is intimate and indeed right over the subway. It has a subtle elegance, yet is not fancy or elaborate. If you have less than 4 guests in your party, you will be seated at the bar. The noise-level is not so high that you can't have a full, relaxed conversation.
2. I encountered no toque-wearing hipsters. Most people were dressed in business or business casual attire. The crowd was a mix of all ages. I suspect that you would be welcome here even if you had on casual clothes.
3. Service was very good. It was not gushing or over-the-top, yet it was efficient and professional. Plates came out reasonably fast, and I never had to ask for more of anything. While they did place the receipt on the bar in front of me, I did not feel rushed.
4. The food is excellent. I had a Spanish mackerel crudo and a red peepers appetizer. Both were tasty and perfect for an appetizer- not too heavy. For the main I had a perfectly-cooked sable fish and a dish of pasta with mushrooms and artichokes. I would go back and have the same thing again without hesitation.
5. Super wine list too. If you like a light red try the Gunther Steinmetz Pinot Noir from the Mosel Valley.
Brothers is a great option for a nicer, casually-elegant meal.