This is my family's go-to place. We always know it's going to be good no matter what we order. We always splits some apps (sea scallops, risotto balls) and then go big with the main dishes. All the pastas are amazing and as for dessert? The tiramisu is classic and a perfect (and light!) way to end the meal.
Hint: check out the back room - it used to be a bank vault. This fact alone increases it's cool factor at least 5 points.