I came here because of a cat with special dietary needs--the food selection at Petco/Petsmart just wasn't cutting it anymore. Wow, does ATYS ever have a huge selection! It was a little overwhelming really, but one of the employees (also a vet student) listened to what I was looking for in a food and helped point me to a few brands/varieties that fit the bill.
Helpful, reasonable prices, knowledgeable staff. Yep, this is my new pet store!