From reading the other reviews, I see this place was on some top 25 places in Pittsburgh list a few years ago. I haven't seen it myself, but have known of this place for a while before my first visit in 2013. It wasn't until my almost 80yo buddy, Mr. Italo Donatucci (world's coolest old Italian dude) brought me one of the best fish sandwiches I ever had that I became hooked! I've had at least 10 since then, but only during the Lent season. I gave my 5 rating based on the fish sandwich alone. Try it without a bun also! Either way you get 3 nice size pieces of fish equal to a pound. You can have your choice of sides, but I always get the small mac n cheese for my side. The staff is always really friendly and service is prompt. It's in a rough neighborhood, but the Rankin police station is right across the street. Almost every visit there I have seen police officers inside mingling with the locals or picking up lunch orders. Soon I plan to make a visit that's not a Friday during Lent to try other menu items.