Just had lunch here. My experience was mediocre. It was one of those, 'Well, I don't exactly regret eating here, but I can't think of a single reason I'd ever come back' places.
I had a Traditional Italian sub and it was okay. I mostly tasted the bread. The sub was no better than Jersey Mike's, who's Italian sub is awesome.
I also had a slice of pepperoni, which again was completely mediocre. It was a small step up from a frozen Tony's, but a large step down from a good pie.
I'm not one to care much about decor, but this place looks like every restaurant on "Restaurant Impossible" where Chef Irvine stops in the entrance, looks annoyed and later takes a sledge hammer to something while yelling at his designer and builder to perform a miracle. I would sum up the decor as, "Got everything out of a dumpster behind a remodeled diner and a big TV".
The best part about my meal was the bottle of Coke and the ranch Doritos.
If you're close and need to grab a quick meal, you won't want to light your face on fire after eating here or anything. However, if you have time, you'd be better served going elsewhere for something really good.
Seeing the other reviews, it's possible I just had a bad meal. More likely those reviewers know the owner. I always get suspicious when someone compliments the chef and owner. Just my $.02.