Okay so I found this place from going to the Black Market up the street conversing with the lady working there, she recommended it, and I dont regret it.
It's located on the corner of Detroit Ave and W 65th street.
Inside there's probably about 25 pinball machines, all in working order, except during a few games, the paddles stopped working on me, but considering their age I didnt care. It's a quarter-fifty cents per game.
The inner decor is awesome, retro paintings of pinball themes on the walls, a velvet picture of Elvis, Betty Boop light up sign, etc.
There's a soda bar with in house soda creations but I didnt get any, owner told me they're working on getting their liquor license soon which should be fun.
The nostalgia is real here if you went to arcades as a kid, which are pretty much dying out like video rental places, so it gives me hope that places like this still exist.