Located inside the Law School at Case Western Reserve University, Schticks is a difficult place to review.
First, you have to deal with the surly owner-manager. Certainly not the most friendly person I have ever met, but I am not sure I can completely blame him. He gets up at like 3am or something, (which would certainly put me in a bad mood) each morning to come to the law school (another reason) to serve coffee, muffins, and wraps to bratty law students (yet another reason).
The muffins rock, the coffee is Seattle's Best, which is fine by me, although many people complain about this point (see bratty law students comment above).
The problem is when you get to the food. The space is small and apparently the owner cannot have a grill or similar in this space due to fire codes. This means that you are mostly left with PB&J or turkey and alfalfa sprout wraps.
The really sad thing is that there is hardly any other decent options in this area, so this place is about as good an option as any. Blackacre (the name of the lounge area with tables to eat the food, haha) is really crowded come lunch time with aforementioned students. Best to grab and go at that hour, if you can.