Came here on a whim after Teharu would not open up 2 empty tables for my 11 person group even though we called ahead. Thank you NYPD for being so accommodating.
My girlfriend and I each enjoyed a 1 topping slice (salami). Very, very good salami and the crust was on point. The consistency of dough seemed to vary across the whole slice, but it didn't take away too much from the flavor. The slice washed down great with a pitcher of an IPA (forgot the brewery).
The waitstaff was incredibly friendly--I need to make a separate note about this. They were sweet, ready to offer suggestions, and split the check perfectly.
All in all, this is a good NYPD Pizza location.