I've been to the Arrogant Butcher twice, and both times have been phenomenal.
I've never had a problem getting a seat during lunch. The hostesses are really sweet and service is always prompt.
I suggest getting the pretzels with the provolone fondue. I made the mistake of filling up on it before my meal but it was SO WORTH IT. I also suggest trying the shrimp appetizer. It was also very good.
I had their burger which was cooked to perfection. My girlf had their fish and chips, also amazing. My beau loves their beer cocktail, the long legged blonde. Its the perfect summer time drink.
I have nothing negative to say about the Arrogant Butcher, except I wish it was a bit closer to me.