Welcome to Ohio City Tabletop! What a refreshing change of pace near a strip of loud crowded bars! I had heard about Tabletop many months ago, and am thrilled that they finally opened a few weeks ago.
I came with 3 friends- it wasn't too crowded when we got there around 7 on a Friday, but by the time we left after 10, it seemed that most tables were taken.
Each person pays $5 (like a cover charge) to have access to unlimited games for the night- and they really have such a huge library of games, and multiples of many games as well. They also have a nice small draft selection or craft beers- reasonably priced, and fun non-alcoholic drinks like kombucha, smoothies, or coffee/ tea. They have a small food menu, which I thought was a little pricey for what you get (really my only beef,which knocked it down to 4 stars for me). I think you're paying a premium because turnover is so low- I imagine most folks stay for 3 hours or more.
Our group had 2 kinds of bitty bites: orange goat, and buff chick dip. Both were really tasty, but small for the price, I thought. 2 friends had smoothies, and they enjoyed them, but again, they were $4.50 for probably an 8 oz smoothie.
The service was very great. Our server was fun, nice, and weird- in an endearing way. He was great about refilling our drinks really often, and when he saw us struggling with a game's rules, he was right there to offer some expertise. It really seemed like all the staff were not only on top of things, but also really wanting to make sure everyone was having a good time. And it really seemed like people did! It was loud, but not rowdy.
Also the decor is simple, but I really liked the vibe. Comfy vintage-y chairs and a subway tile bar. Some cool custom art on the walls. I dig this place, and I'll definitely be back!