If you're going to MezzaNotte for American style Italian or cheap pizza, this probably won't be the best experience for you. Yes, the prices are more expensive than the average casual Italian experience, but the food and service make it worth it. Try the entree dishes or authentic pastas. At the end of the day, the 3.5 star rating just means I've got this gem more to myself, but to be fair the food and service quality here exceeds other options on a consistent basis.