This is a tough one! 5 stars for a historic venue with a lot of charm and amazing concerts! Just got back from seeing a great show by Volcano Choir and plan to go back to see a couple shows in October.
But.... I have to average that out with the 3 stars based on the more practical factors involved in reviews....the floors were so sticky I was having trouble lifting my feet in some areas, the carpets and chairs were filthy and the women's bathroom was really inexcusably disgusting. Just disgusting. If this place cleaned up it would be my favorite place in Madison to see a show for sure!