Most restaurants are usually a disappointment. This one certainly is not.
I was not sure what to expect; the downtown core of Markham is currently under construction. Immediately after stepping into Good Catch Boil, that feeling of a place that is not quite finished disappeared. The restaurant is spacious but feels cozy. There is a pleasant scent of real lemon in the place (for those of you that are sensitive to scents as I am).
We were seated right away and offered drinks, and then food, at the right times.
The lobster roll was absolutely delicious; the bread was perfect and the lobster (with garlic hot butter) tasted unencumbered by other seasonings that would detract from the lobster. The soft-shell crab sandwich, which I 'borrowed' from my wife, was incredible. I usually don't pay attention to the sides (fries etc) but I must say that they all tasted fresh. The staff was friendly and helpful (I suggest asking them for recommendations).
Shortly after we left, we wanted to return again.
Not only will I return, I will return tonight. I loved the place, the staff, the atmosphere, and the fresh-tasting food.
I would suggest getting there early. As we were leaving, there was quite a line-up.
My only gripe with the place is that they are not open for lunch.