*AMENDMENT*
Ok I am amending my review due to the fact that I've now been in Cleveland almost 3 years and our experience with OCP has gone completely downhill. The pizza is still "ok" but over time has gotten greasier and greasier. I think the fact that they put the 'za on wax paper, which doesn't absorb anything, causes the grease puddle - however, I'm not claiming to be a scientist.
The reason for the 1 star rating is as follows: Someone who works at OCP gave out our personal contact information to a delivery driver. My boyfriend started receiving text messages FROM THE PIZZA DELIVERY DRIVER on a social level on nights that WE HAD NOT ORDERED A PIZZA. Creepy as shit, right? Right. Needless to say we haven't ordered pizza from there again... (shudders).
++++++++++++++++++++++
My boyfriend and I just moved from Chicago and have really become accustomed to thin crust pizzas. Actually I'd consider myself a pizza snob, so the task of finding a new pizza joint in my area seemed rather daunting. I was told to try Ohio City Pizzeria, so I figured we should start setting them up and knocking them down as quickly as possible.
The woman on the phone was extremely nice. When I asked if they made 'thin crust pizzas' she said she could make it as thin as possible, which was fine by me. I ordered my pizza and it was delivered to our apt in Tremont in 45 min. Everything went smoothly and the pizza was really good.
I'd also like to add that they have green olives as a topping option and apparently that isn't a standard topping in Cleveland, so they get brownie points for that as well.
I can't speak to the actual establishment because I've only had delivery.
We've been in Cleveland for 1 month and have ordered pizza from OCP 2x already. I'm definitely going call them again.