I picked up some cupcakes on a recent trip to the West Side Market and was really impressed with both the flavor offerings and quality. The S'mores, Buckeye, and Peanut Butter and Jelly were awesome. The Carrot Cake was great too, and I am generally not a Carrot Cake fan. These are closer to standard size cupcakes, rather than the giant size ones you often find at other places, and the prices reflect that. $9.50 for a half dozen is more than fair.
I don't get to the market very often, but when I do, this will be a regular stop from now on.