I've seen two shows here: Fiddler on the Roof and A Christmas Story. Both shows have been absolutely amazing. My brother-in-law is a season ticket holder and I have rarely heard any negative critique of any of the main shows.
In A Christmas Story, which I saw this week 12.1.16, I especially would like to point out the talent of the boy who played Ralphie (it wasn't the actor who typically does), the man paying father and the woman cast as the teacher.
The food is typically pretty good; I've been warned to stick with beef dishes as the others tend to be pretty dry. I had the tri-tip this time, and it was delicious.
Our server on this visit, while very sweet, was either distracted or very new. She forgot to bring out a soup after being asked multiple times, a medium rare prime rib came out all gray and all desserts were ordered a la mode and none came out with ice cream.
Overall, my experiences here have been quite positive. I recommend choosing this theater for your arts enjoyment.