My husband and I, along with a couple of friends, gave this place a try not too long ago. The place was dead, but we figured this was due to the fact it was later on a weekday evening. The space they have there is fantastic, but seems to be haunted by the ghosts of the many restaurants that failed before they moved in. Anyways...
Overall, the food was a tad underwhelming. I have had way better cheesesteaks at the food court in the mall! My fries were decent though. I ordered an old fashioned and was hoping for a better presentation then what I received. It seemed like the restaurant wants to boast that they have a great bar with knowledgable staff, but we must have got the D squad. That being said, we were well attended to by our waiter overall.
I probably wouldn't go back to this place because nothing seemed to stand out about it. My advice: there are plenty of upstanding American restaurant/bars that Haymaker's can't even compare to.