We don't normally do buffets as we have food allergies to contend with. Having said that, the "chef" did come out and helped advise of which foods to stay clear of.
Seemed to be a decent buffet for the most part but not having tried others especially in Vegas, it is hard for me to rate. I would give it a 3 star but you have to be selective in what you choose. The basics are good eg prime rib, spinach, rice pilaf, mashed potatoes. For the club price, thought it was very reasonable especially compared to other alternatives we have up in Canada.
I'd read others reviews for comparisons to other Vegas buffets as they seem to have a better appreciation for what else is available. But it seems to me that no lineups and reasonable food to satisfy both adults and kids at a decent price wins them a 3.