I met some friends here to celebrate a birthday and I was very impressed! Our waiter was great and very attentive. We were a somewhat complicated table, splitting bills and being on a time-crunch, but he handled everything with grace.
We ordered the pretzel bites to start, which are DANGEROUS! I could eat a whole basket by myself.
The food was delicious and they have a great selection of wines. I ordered the Prime Rib, which you can only get on Saturdays. It was truly cooked to perfection! I also tried the scallops and the filet, both of which melt in your mouth.
Overall, the Butcher is a cool spot right in the heart of downtown. It's worth a try!
PRO TIP: The hostesses won't seat you until your whole group has arrived and they don't accept reservations. If you're meeting a group or headed over to a sporting event or concert across the street, make sure to give yourself ample time!