I think Ben L. is right. They offer a wide variety of brews -- rotating them so that there's usually two choices -- but *sometimes* I don't think they know them, all that well? I've come here and had coffees that are great; other times, unremarkable. Apparently, to pull great espressos you have to know your beans and I suspect there's not enough focus.
I'm also deducting a star because of the pastries-from-a-box, thing.
On the PLUS side, the owner's a great guy and he's fighting a battle with the Office de la langue francaise over the extra "f" in Caffe. Seriously. So he deserves support. (he's French Quebecois himself, btw).