Caliente has moved into the spot where Ordinary Joe's used to be. They've only been open for like a week, but we've already hit them up twice for delivery and once in the restaurant for dinner (don't judge!). It's been a bit of a mixed bag. When we dined in, we tried their pizza and buffalo chicken rolls. The dough they use for their pizza/breads/rolls is definitely distinct...it has a lightness and sweetness to it that makes it stand out from typical Pittsburgh pizza. I think maybe it's a bit less chewy, which I like. Their pizza sauce is a bit on the tart side, but because their crust is sweeter, it actually works well. As for atmosphere, it's pretty similar inside to how Ordinary Joe's was...clean and modern with a bit of a sports bar feel. It was quite busy when we went, and the service was not great (hopefully it's just opening-week kinks that are being worked out). The couple of times we ordered delivery, everything arrived quickly, but the food was more disappointing than it was when we dined in. The cheesy bread didn't come with sauce, and the Italian hoagie lacked Italian dressing (dry hoagie...gross). The buffalo chicken hoagie that we also ordered was not good...way overstuffed with fries, not very much chicken, and drenched with so much hot sauce that it was almost inedible (and I'm a girl who likes her food spicy!) Their fries in theory seem like they would be good (they're fresh cut), but they take no care to keep them crispy during delivery, so when they arrived, they were a soggy mess. Attention to detail seems to be sorely lacking for delivery orders, which is a shame.
Anyway, overall, the food was much better during our dine-in experience than delivery, so perhaps we'll stick with that (even though service needs to improve). They just opened, so hopefully things get better as they adjust to their new space. Until then, I can't give them much higher than a middling 3.