Disappointed to say the least. I decided to visit because of the rating but boy was I surprised. To start with, we ordered the sampler appetizer and everything seemed to be the same that you'd get from a bar at midnight. The fried mushrooms were in a batter that seemed freezer burned with bad taste. The chicken fingers were okay. I didn't try the cheese sticks or zucchini and the onion rings did have a hint of beer batter. That was the best part of it. We had to ask our server twice for plates and when they did arrive, one had cheese on it the dishwasher couldn't get off. We ordered the Romano's Special large pizza. Pretty much like a supreme anywhere else. All of the toppings were frozen except for perhaps the onions. Nothing New York about that at all. New Yorkers know how to make pizza. We both had iced tea and our server only visited us once after the pizza came near the end of our meal so we both sat there throughout our meal with empty glasses. We won't be going back.