5 stars for New York style pizza
1 star for Sicilian
I have lived in Old Town for almost 2 years and have been on a mission to find good pizza. I discovered Joe's a couple of months ago when a friend had ordered it, and I loved it! It was the New York style pizza, and it was perfect for me-- just greasy enough, lots of cheese, not too much sauce. The last 2 times I've ordered, I've eaten an entire 18' pizza with only one other person!
BUT...last night my bf and I made the mistake of ordering the Sicilian pizza. He and I both loved the Sicilan pizza at a place called Jet's pizza prior to moving to Scottsdale, which doesn't have a Jet's. The Sicilian at Joe's is nothing like Jet's, unfortunately. It is all crust. I like thick crust when it's good, but this was just dry, bland, and seriously at least an inch thick. There was not much cheese or sauce, and, even if there had been, it would still have been overpowered by the crust. I even tried dipping in ranch, and, still, all I got was crust. What made it worse was that the Sicilian only came in one size-- 18 x 12! So, we paid almost $30 for one pizza and just ended up throwing away most of it.
I will keep ordering from Joe's, but, from now on, I'll stick with the New York style pizza.