I came here for Winterlicious and it was pretty much exactly what I expected. It was delicious food with friendly staff.
I had a veal stew served on polenta, which was extremely flavourful. The panna cotta desert was probably the best I've tasted. Their calamari is exactly what you'd expect from a quality Italian place.
Normally, I'd give this place 4 stars, but there was just one thing that was a bit weird about this place that took a star off (and honestly I don't know if maybe it should gain a star or lose a star because of it...). The ground floor was full when we got there, so they seated us in the upstairs dining room. The tables and chairs up there look straight out of grandma's kitchen (if grandma bought her furniture in 1982). In some ways, it made the place feel cheap; in other ways, it made it feel homey.
Either way, I'd recommend this restaurant to someone wanting the St. Clair West experience.