Went there today for some late lunch, and I want this place to be my new home. The diner decor is absolutely on point, from the actual booths to the plastic condiments bottles. Overall, if you are in for an as-seen-on-my-fave-movies vibe, it's right on, with the exception of more modern (but undeniably quality) music. The service was absolutely incredible, It really doesn't get better than that. Honestly, I really couldn't find a single complaint even if i tried to.
As for the food, I ordered a beef burger with a side of putine, and while the latter was just fries in gravy topped with melted marble cheese, it was still pretty good. All i can say is that it's much more than you can expect from a 10 dollar burger and fries anywhere else. My friends and i also had milkshakes (Vanilla, strawberry and chocolate) and my vanilla was probably the best milkshake I've ever had (and it was even served in a classic tall milkshake glass). Really, its the real life five dollar milkshake (actually only $3.75)
NOTE that that hours on yelp are currently wrong, and while i didn't take a picture of the new times, I am pretty sure they are open until five for most days instead of 4.