Reliably good. I've been a few times and tried all the pizzas by now, haven't found a single one that I didn't like.
Slight disappointment- I loved the 5 mushroom pizza the first time I had it, but the second time they overloaded it with mushrooms and it just wasn't the same.
But def one of my go to places around here for good pizza. They also allow half/half of any kinds of specialty pizzas (so you can try all different kinds).