I'd heard that the bagels here are pre-made/frozen and not boiled, so I was VERY skeptical about trying them out. I was incredibly and very pleasantly surprised.
The bagels are actually really good and wonderfully chewy. The sandwiches contain top quality ingredients in some very creative combinations. My dining companion and I tried the Nagel and the Hummus sandwiches and found them both to be delicious. Two sandwiches, two chips and two drinks was only about $15. They have high end chips in all sorts of crazy and yummy sounding flavors, which is a neat twist on the traditional chips & sandwiches combo.
Service is very good and friendly, and they were very generous about letting me sample one of the cream cheese flavors (berry inferno = yum). It's very student oriented and had a nice atmosphere that was welcoming even to non-students.
On the down side, there is almost no seating in the place so plan on going somewhere else to sit and enjoy your meal. If they add some tables, I'll up it to 5 stars. The sandwiches are bagel-sized (duh), which isn't that big so this isn't the place to go if you're starving and looking for a huge meal. For a quick breakfast or lunch, though, this is the perfect place.
I live and work off campus and think this place is good enough to justify driving around at $4 a gallon looking for parking, which is saying a lot! I will definitely be going back!