DO NOT ORDER THE CHEESE CURDS. Seriously, worst cheese curds in Madison. They had too much bland, cake-y batter that overpowered the very mild curds, which I think were inside the batter, but they were so melted it was just goo (Not enough cheese in the cheese curd - how is that even possible?) Even the side sauce was disappointing - watery and bland.
I really wanted to like this place - big tables, large selection of homebrewed beer, photos of the Atwood neighborhood around town. Atmosphere is nice, sadly the food is meh. I had the salmon sandwich, which was more like a mayonnaise-y salmon salad. It was alright after adding some salt.
The beer is the highlight of this place, lots of selection and they offer beer flights for tasting and figuring out your favorites.