My family and I have been coming to Lahore Tikka House for the past 15 years. It's one of those places we take company to, and it's consistently good. My personal preferences are the lamb karahi, chicken seekh kabobs, butter chicken, the beef biryani and garlic naan.
I myself am Indian and am often picky about Indian food because I know and want it to taste a certain way. Lahore Tikka House comes the closest to my mom and grandma's cooking. The only reason I didn't give them 5 stars was that they use more oil then I'd personally prefer, but still, well worth the trip!