The Key West Shrimp House was such an amazing find when driving around Madison, Indiana looking for food. Located right on the river you almost feel like you are at a local eatery on vacation. The staff was super friendly, and the place was packed when we went, so I knew it would be good! I'm not understanding the 3-star rating! With all that being said, don't expect a five-star seafood restaurant. This is a mom and pop kind of restaurant, so my star rating is based on having gone in with that expectation. (Hopefully, this makes sense?) While waiting for a table we headed to the back for a drink at the tiny bar. Just be glad it's there...you and the workers must deal with the cards you're dealt lol! The bread and salad bar was good, and the fish and sides were delicious (this is my go-to word). The desserts are homemade and looked mouthwatering, but I was just too full. Please give the Key West Shrimp House a try and decide for yourself if it's worth a second visit. For me it was and my friends who visited after agreed!