Aussie Rules gets 5 stars because I've been here at least 4 times and not once did I walk out not feeling I had a great time. Unless you are lame (and those who are likely know it), this is guaranteed fun. Some might consider it a pricey night with the cover charge, potential food orders and tipping the pianists if you so choose, but it's worth it if you splurge.
Should you go back more than once, it's best to leave a year or so in between to avoid hearing many of the same songs. I've only ever gone on a weekend evening and it's typically packed.
April Challenge: The Underdog 3/30