Hmm I really didn't expect this so I'm hoping it was just this one flavor. The salted oreo, which the man serving me said was the most popular, just didn't work for me at all.
Flavor-wise, the salt was tipping the scales.. just salt salt salt. The oreo pieces were there but all I could taste was the salt.
The ice cream itself, I can echo other reviewers here that complain of it being "watery." It's definitely a consistency thing. With all of the rave reviews one after another, I wonder if this was just a bad batch.
I'm hoping to come back soon and give it another shot and hope that another flavor provides that creaminess one craves when getting ice cream. Staff was nice and told me a lot about their process, but I left disappointed.