I really want to like this place. I really, truly do. I live across the street, so I've been here countless times and every time I hope for a fun, great time. Not so much. The food, in my opinion, is just alright. I've never eaten anything here that I think about later, craving a return trip. A lot of people I've spoken with think of this place as a dessert place. Again, not so much. The desert case is similar to your little corner bakery. Cheesecakes, tortes, and cannolis, but usually nothing I get super excited about. Maybe I'm missing something.
My least favorite element about this place is the service. It's slow and inattentive--even sitting at the bar. I've been here in the double digits and have yet to have good service. That's a bummer.
That said, it's not a complete bust. In my opinion, the best way to eat here is to sit at the bar during happy hour, munching on $3 plates. You can get a decent burger, fish tacos, and a few other dishes for an excellent price. It's the best value in terms of their food. They do have a pretty tasty martini list as well.