I wish there was a way to give 4.5 stars, because this place is basically five star material but I came away feeling like I didn't get enough food for my money.
The servers working were pleasant and smiling, you get an overwhelming sense that they have a lot of regulars and with good reason. My guess is that once you're there 2-3 times they'll recognize you, remember your name and what your order was. This just feels like that kind of place.
I got a Salmon sandwich on a bagel and it was fantastic. I paid $5.95 for it and for that price I was hoping for 30% more food but that is the only slight I could possibly give this place.
Otherwise this is everything a quaint local eatery should be.