I'm on the fence between 2 and 3 stars, but it's better than average so I'll give them 3.
I grew up on this pizza. After moving away from the area years ago - I stopped in the other day to recapture a memory from my younger days. The strong points - excellent sausage and decent flavored crust...much like I remember. The weaknesses - sauce that seems to have much less flavor than in years gone by, and cheese that is definitely different - less salty/buttery than I remember. Unfortunately, that's 2/3s of the overall flavor, so it really came up flat IMHO. Still, it's a good bit better than the chains.
For years, I always thought Antonio's pizza came closest to replicating the 'good old days' of the Angie's, Pizza King, and Mama Mia's pizza shops of the Broadview/Rt 21/Pleasant Valley corridor. Sadly, it's still the only shop in the area that has that signature flavor.