I've been to Philthy Phillys twice now and I was really looking forward to this place opening up nearby my home.
The first time I had a Philly Poutine which I thought was odd didn't come with green peppers, onion, and mushroom standard but I asked for mushrooms and green peppers and they said sure. The poutine was good regular size filled me up and I wouldn't order a Philthy poutine unless I was splitting it with someone else. My complaint however was the wait time it took 15 minutes from order to getting food which I felt was too long for poutine however this was within their first week of opening so I chalked it up to that.
I went back today and ordered a Philthy sized Philly cheese steak and after waiting for almost 20 minutes they realized they accidentally gave my sandwich to someone else, I was pretty irritated and thought something was off when someone who ordered after me was getting a philly before me with that said they refunded me for my Philly and promptly made a new one which was ready in about 5 minute after the mix up. I appreciated that because if they didn't refund me I probably wouldn't have been back again. Anyway onto the Philly I finally got....
Good steak, nice and juicy and they have a lot of sauce and topping options and even various cheese options although I stuck to the original steak mushroom, onion, green pepper and provolone formula without cheese wiz and I added hot sauce and their Philthy sauce which was like a BBQ sauce.
So why 3 stars, well I dock one star for how long I've had to wait both times and I dock another because I compare this place directly to Retro Burger in Ajax which is my go to in Pickering/Ajax for both Philly cheesesteak and poutine and I could have had both a Philly cheesesteak and poutine for the cost of 1 Philthy Philly cheese steak.
This place has good food but I find them a little too expensive and they need to improve the wait times.