I love SubStation sandwiches. Their bread is really weirdly good and unlike any other bread I've ever had. I should have taken a picture of my sandwich, but I was too busy engulfing it to pause and pose it. It's just the right amount of chewy and salty, and it's perfect.
The service is always really fast, and I am in love with their All Cheese. I think it's #12. Get it all the way, and you have to ask for pickles. These shops sometimes look a little run-down, but the food makes up for it. It's good and local, so you get all the benefits of Jersey Mikes or Subway without feeling like a soul-less corporate whore.