I guess the small piece of fish last time was a fluke.
Amanda, the Duke of Somerset marketing manager, responded to my previous Yelp review and let me know that the portion was unusually small. She got in touch with the restaurant and made sure they corrected that issue.
When I revisited this past week, I was not disappointed. The fish was double the size of the one I had last time, at least in width, and the angle of the picture doesn't do it justice. Just like last time, it was fried nicely. The batter is not overly thick, so you get the perfect amount of crunch with the fish. I still wish there were more fries and that they'd be on the plate instead of a container, just to give it that hearty full-plate look. But I was very pleased with my visit overall.
My server, Kate, was very friendly and attentive.
It's not cheap, but if you want good fish and chips around the Bay and Gerard area, I would recommend this place.